We’re amazed that Toby being “A” stayed a secret. In this day and age with Twitter and Facebook and all the spoilers — we’re amazed.

Right? We’re all really pleased with that. In fact, we gave ourselves a big pat on the back the second it broke because we were waiting. Everybody from the social media department of our show was scanning the internet every day since we filmed that. We even filmed three alternate endings: one with Tyler Blackburn, and another one with Lindsey Shaw [Paige McCullers] being in the hoodie, and then we all turn around. So I didn’t even really know if they were going to use me as “A” at that point. There was no way to tell, which was really smart of them. We really did such a solid job of keeping it secret, and I’m glad that it worked out that way because it added to the shock value.